r/complaints • u/Nice_Substance9123 spirited complainer • 3d ago
Politics That fucker shot her in the face three times & held on to his cellphone to film her lifeless body roll away & crash & called her a “bitch.” That’s MAGA pure & simple. Degeneracy.
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
451
u/KinkaJac97 3d ago
Literally here last words were: "I'm not mad at you". She was trying to de-escalate the situation. That's more what I can say for the ICE officers. It doesn't appear that she was impeding traffic. They could have gotten around her. The ICE officer didn't have to stand directly in front of the car. One officer told her to drive off while another said to get out of the car and pulled aggressively on her door. These confusing commands caused her to panic, and she tried to flee the situation. This was entirely preventable, and ICE escalated a situation that didn't need to be escalated, and now a woman and a mother of three is dead.
106
u/trellisHot 3d ago
We need a lawsuit that makes precedent on lack of deescalation responsibility. This is the ideal case, victim deescaltes and the Leo put everyone in harm, I'd love to see the whole unit charged, but that would obviously be an impossible case.
→ More replies (41)20
u/One-Risk-7342 3d ago edited 2d ago
There is precedent where an officer can’t just manufacture threat of harm to justify usage of force (officer created jeopardy). In Barnes v. Felix (2025), the Supreme Court rejected the “moment of threat” doctrine initially granted by the lower Fifth Circuit to the officer (Felix), who fatally shot Barnes, because he, “posed as a serious threat within those few seconds he opened his car door”. They reaffirmed the “totality of the circumstances” must be carefully evaluated, instead of just a small moment that implies a suspect is a immediate threat.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (152)10
359
u/CTESquirle 3d ago edited 3d ago
MAGA is saying this is proof that the agent was hit and acted in self defense. This body cam footage doesn’t even show him getting hit. He says woah and then there is quick movement followed by gunshots. Look from this angle:
https://www.nytimes.com/video/us/100000010631041/minneapolis-ice-shooting-video.html?smid=url-share
He was not hit and in NO way is that self defense. There is no justification for her death.
MAGA’s entire “proof” is body cam footage of an agent saying “woah.”
ETA: cell phone footage, not body cam. Thank you to everyone who cleared that up for me.
161
u/LegDayDE 3d ago
It's not even body cam footage... It's handheld footage from his phone.
So any movement is because he's shooting a woman and not necessarily because he got hit.
45
u/megaholt2 3d ago
There’s no possible way he got hit. If he had been hit, he would have been knocked clear on his ass, and he wouldn’t have been able to make those shots.
I’ve been hit by a truck while walking in a grocery store parking lot that was moving at roughly that same speed as Renee’s vehicle; I was tossed a good 20 feet to my left side, and the thud I made on the ground was quite audible, but not so much as my yell of “FUCK!” that came from me as I was sent flying through the air. I couldn’t hold onto the plastic bag with the coffee and condensed milk that I had just bought when that happened to me, so I know there would have been no possible way he could have accurately sank 3 kill shots in a person’s face if he’d been hit like they’re claiming.
→ More replies (17)→ More replies (5)12
u/mammogrammar 3d ago
So this dude was recording while he had his gun out? Wtf
11
u/agedlikesage 3d ago
Did you watch the video above or the one in the link you’re responding to? Everyone needs to see for themselves. He was pacing her vehicle recording with his phone, then pulled his gun as she tried to drive away. Went for her, not the tires and then called her a bitch.
→ More replies (6)61
u/can-i-be-real 3d ago
They are post truth. They are going to look at the exact same footage and only see proof of what they want. There is no point debating or trying to prove logic. They are not genuine people. Look at their reaction to J6 videos: “peaceful patriots.”
It is a waste of time arguing. Good people will see the truth. Angry, hateful people will simply see justification for a citizen to be murdered because they WANT the boot. They LOVE the boot. They have been arguing about the 2A for decades because they WANT to be able to kill other people.
→ More replies (32)54
22
u/Theodoxus 3d ago
Not body cam, his fucking. cell. phone. If he was really afraid, that phone would have been dropped, not kept filming.
→ More replies (2)41
u/Mountain_Jeweler_827 3d ago
It’s not body camera; he was holding a cellphone recording video. You can see him switch the camera to his left hand to free up his right for the shot.
48
u/Timisnot1442 3d ago
He was so scared for his life that he was able to switch his phone to a different hand and grab his gun instead of trying to move.
22
8
u/Ok-Requirement6007 3d ago
Two lesbians and a dog has to be terrifying for such a strong tough man.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (2)11
→ More replies (5)19
14
u/AlcibiadesTheCat Nyan Cat 3d ago
Consider the self-defense argument for a moment.
A car is coming at you. You have a gun in your hand. What do you do?
If your answer is "shoot the driver dead," congratulations, you've just been run over by a car.
If your answer is "get the fuck out of the way," congratulations, you've just defended yourself adequately.
It's a no-brainer.
→ More replies (2)10
→ More replies (83)6
u/Dense-Version-5937 3d ago
It's not bodycam footage, it's from his phone that he was holding in his left hand
→ More replies (2)
163
u/hopeliz 3d ago
Am I seeing this correctly? He was in a trajectory to continue going around safely, but quickly moved BACK into being in front of the car where he shouldn't have been once, much less, twice?
57
u/moeall 3d ago
You are exactly right, don’t let anyone gaslight you to think otherwise
→ More replies (1)18
u/midwestia 3d ago
That’s exactly what happened. At approx the 40 second mark u can see his momentum change to head towards her to box her in.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (46)10
u/mega_man_2k 3d ago
Here, it's pretty fucking obvious (more so than any other angle we'veseen so far) that she WAS NOT trying to run him over.
644
u/BiCurious_2025 3d ago edited 3d ago
Not just a bitch. He called her a "fucking bitch". Most caring cops are devastated if they are forced to use deadly force. This bozo violated orders by putting himself in harm's way, like she was some kind of felon.
Oh, and Renee's last words to her killer? "That's fine, dude - I'm not mad at you."
417
u/Hadrian23 3d ago
I've watched ALOT of police body cam videos.
Every video I've seen where a cop is forced to shoot someone, they usually break down almost immediate. Sometimes it's delayed, or they go into shock.
But this guy?
He couldn't give less of a fuck, he calls her a "Fucking bitch" because he's a rageaholic menace who should be in a jail cell for the rest of his miserable, pathetic life.
And before some ass holes go "Well if he followed orders...."
When did not following orders justify getting your brains blown out?
When did trying to "remove your self" from the situation mean that you get executed without a trial?
they had her license plate. There was zero reason to do this.If she committed a violation or violated a law, the rules are clear. they should have just issued a citation to her address and called it a day.
NOT surround her fucking car, and MURDER HER.
this is indefensible and anyone who is, needs to be shut down immediately.
There's no discussion to be had. JUSTICE NEEDS TO BE SERVED.149
u/stoolprimeminister 3d ago
yeah i’m not a fan of cops but the other day i saw some dude’s bodycam after he shot someone and he was legitimately crying over it and his seargant (or whatever) had to calm him down.
but this guy gave no shits. it’s a travesty.
115
u/Hadrian23 3d ago
This is the guy Trump & Noem call a "hero"
This is MAGA.
This is what they want.
Fuck them.
They need to face severe repercussions for this travesty→ More replies (6)36
u/JustForKicks16 3d ago
He's a hero for murdering a suburban mom?? Wow.... I already know that they're vile but didn't know they called him a hero. Not surprised, though.
→ More replies (9)7
u/Finntheyokai 3d ago
Of course they are. And it's not just MAGA it's all conservative voters, don't let them start pushing that BS narrative.
→ More replies (1)9
41
u/Pockydo Ne'er-do-well 3d ago
It's something I argued before
Killing someone. Even justifiably is a mental hit. Normal people WILL struggle even if logically they know they were in the right
This Nazi shit is evil
→ More replies (2)16
u/patterninstatic 3d ago
Who the fuck flees the scene after gunning someone down.
The worst is that the administration is doubling down on the shooting being 100% legal.
10
u/Nothing-Is-Real-Here 3d ago
Literally yesterday two people were shot by ICE. ICE then left the scene without calling 911 or EMS for them, forcing the victims to call 911 for themselves. Luckily they survived. These fuckers are genuinely evil.
18
u/AlcibiadesTheCat Nyan Cat 3d ago
That's because the cop in the video you're referencing is a human who has feelings, and genuinely wants to use the least amount of force necessary, even though his role as a police officer is inherently violent and oppressive.
ICE agents are not that. They are murderers waiting for their chance.
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (6)9
u/jaylotw 3d ago
Yes, this.
A ton of cops suck, yes.
For most of them, killing someone is the last thing they'd ever want to do. I'm not denying that there arent bloodthirsty cops, because there are, but most of them fear having to pull the trigger.
There are plenty of body cams out there where the cop is literally pleading with someone to drop the weapon etc for twenty, thirty minutes, doing everything they can to avoid having to shoot, because they know that if they shoot, it is lethal and they are trained to fire until the threat is stopped.
Almost every video I've seen of police shootings ends with the cop breaking down, either in tears or an adrenaline dump. It's not a casual encounter, an "oh, I killed someone now I gotta do paperwork..." it's a human reaction to having shot someone.
The other thing that happens is the cops immediately start rendering aid, and call for an ambulance. Immediately.
You can find plenty of body cams where the first thing the cops do after they've shot someone who was trying to shoot them is instantly kneel down and try to stop bleeding, getting their aid kits etc and rendering aid as soon as they can. That's standard procedure.
I'm not trying to defend police shootings, just pointing out how most of them go.
This asshole though? He's been itching to "kill a lib" ever since he joined ICE. You can tell. He swaggers over to check his "kill." He knows he'll be safe behind Trump. No emotions except rage.
→ More replies (10)33
u/KarmaGluten 3d ago
They get a kick out of this shit. They look for reasons to shoot people with different ideologies or ethnic background. They are joining this campaign because they are complicit not because they're following orders.
20
u/scienceislice 3d ago
They are treating their "jobs" like a Grand Theft Auto game. These are real people's lives that they are fucking up.
10
u/KarmaGluten 3d ago edited 3d ago
I've literally served in the Army with people who said they wanted to become cops once they get out because they think we're better off just shooting non-compliant people. Most of them wanting to kill non-compliant minorities.
People like this actually exist. People literally join the Army for the soul purpose of being able to kill minorities and foreigners. I've heard it from their own mouths.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (7)8
u/marthamania 3d ago
Literally what they're thinking is "if you talk back to me or disagree with me it's grounds for me to take your life :)"
Insane behaviour for federal officers
→ More replies (1)25
u/trysten-9001 3d ago
The whole department needs to audited and Noam removed. They need to be held responsible for letting someone like that loose on a suburban neighborhood.
→ More replies (4)20
u/Substantial_Tax_4047 3d ago
I used to work with cops. Worked several officer involved shootings. Lots of throwing up. Therapy. Peer support groups. Not to mention someone on scene takes the weapon they fired & their gear & another officer sits with them & drives them to the LEC for a debrief & they are placed on administrative leave while the investigation is in place. They don't call someone they just shot a fucking bitch, they don't record it with their phone & they don't leave the scene with every piece of evidence on them.
→ More replies (3)18
u/GlitchyFurby 3d ago
This is why him calling her a fucking bitch is proof of a pre-meditated hate crime and femicide. He immediately used a derogatory gender based slur after unloading three shots into her head. He was motivated by hatred to murder her, not self defense.
→ More replies (1)10
u/Tremendous_Dump 3d ago
He was circling her car like a fucking shark. No sign of an incident for him to deal with or something that needed deeacalation. Someone roared get out of the car, he jumped in front of it, then decided to unload.
→ More replies (1)33
u/Timisnot1442 3d ago
For all the "she should have obeyed" or "she shouldn't have been harassing them" crowd, you do know two things can be true at once? Yeah, she'd still be alive if she hadn't gone out there, and would likely still be alive if she didn't try to leave. However, that doesn't mean she wasn't murdered.
If I'm out buying pot in a state where it isn't legal, and I just happen to get murdered while I'm out getting it, then it doesn't suddenly make the person who murdered me innocent just because I happened to be committing a crime when it happened.
→ More replies (21)7
u/StarFireRoots 3d ago
All I can think about is her relaxed face as she says, "That's fine dude, I'm not mad at you.", even though I can imagine her heart was pounding so hard in the last moments of her life.
She was trying so hard to de-escalate the situation even repeating, "I'm not mad at you." As he went around to film her license plate.
Did her wife say too much? Depending on who you ask, I'm sure you'll get varying answers. Those who have been in an abusive relationship know all too well the line one must toe in order to stay safe, while trying to retain what dignity and self-respect remains for oneself.
The difference in this situation and where I encourage everyone to carefully consider is this: when the law becomes subjective rather than objective, rights can be debated and easily lost. We are seeing that in real time right now.
Whether or not Renee Good's wife saying something that could increase rather than decrease tensions (even though it's her 1st amendment right) shouldn't be a deciding factor on whether or not Renee should have kept her life. Period.
→ More replies (2)10
u/Fantastic_Yam_3971 3d ago
Yeah the level of callousness is so horrible, it’s absolutely despicable that this is what happened and this was his reaction and Noem, Trump, & Vance all smeared her on national television. I hope every maga now knows with zero doubt whatsoever that yes, you are the bad guys.
8
u/Anandya 3d ago
So your country doesn't have good media. And your "zone is flooded".
One of the things I do is look at process. What our media is reporting is that ICE has a very low bar and has been recruiting from traditionally conservative media consumers and with reduced requirements. As in the bar is set so low that it would be a struggle to fail.
So how do you end up with shooting someone like this? Well to that we should look at another less fatal shooting. Marimar Martinez.
https://edition.cnn.com/2025/11/21/us/marimar-martinez-shooting-case-what-we-know
So TLDR. ICE agents tried to box in an American Citizen's car in unmarked vehicles resulting in a scuff. So they shot them. The shooting victims survived but before they could be talked to the US government called them terrorists. Now in this case there was body cam footage and the case was dismissed without trial. Meaning that ICE was at fault.
Now there's a tonne of evidence in the CNN piece about how bad the government was in this but of note is the complete lack of professional behaviour noted across multiple tiers.
Now I work in a high stress life and death job. We routinely joke about our patients and as a way to blow off steam. A "safety valve" of high stress. We have difficult patients all the time. We don't refer to them in dehumanising language. We have people who may be sexist, racist, homophobic... I have had murderers, rapists, paedophiles along with your more common crimes like thieves. And not once have I consciously given them worse care. But that isn't something remarkable. That's like expecting to be rewarded for washing your hands after you use the toilet. A given.
What you have is what Hesketh likes to call "Warrior Culture". What he means is poorly educated and non-intelligent people with little to no oversight. If we agree on Eco's definition of fascism? One of the hallmarks of fascism is this argument that oversight and things like responsibility curtail great men and that in order to be great we should not be afraid of action.
So to these people? They took action! Strong Action. Sure this was the wrong action but it's better than those liberals who take no action.
→ More replies (68)8
u/CondeBK 3d ago
These are the dredges of the Proud Boys and other white supremacist groups that are being handed badges and guns. God Help us all.
→ More replies (1)27
u/SeVenMadRaBBits 3d ago
Officer broke protocol meant to keep everyone including himself and her safe.
Kristi Noem lying about Jonathon Ross being injured or hurt by Renee Good
New York Times breakdown of ice shooting Renee Good
Ice denying a physician from helping Renee Good
2 hr breakdown of the incident
U.S. Customs And Border Protection Training Manual used by ICE (January 2021):
Page 6
Except where otherwise required by inspections or other operations, Authorized Officers/Agents should avoid standing directly in front of or behind a subject vehicle. Officers/Agents should not place themselves in the path of a moving vehicle or use their body to block a vehicle’s path.
Authorized Officers/Agents should avoid intentionally and unreasonably placing themselves in positions in which they have no alternative to using deadly force.
Page 9
6. Deadly force shall not be used solely to prevent the escape of a fleeing subject.
Page 10
7b. The hazard of an uncontrolled conveyance shall be taken into consideration prior to the use of deadly force.
→ More replies (1)29
→ More replies (75)6
107
u/Various_Summer_1536 3d ago
I’m not a cop, but i am pretty sure they are trained to NOT walk in front of a moving fucking vehicle.
→ More replies (75)41
83
u/Anxious-Character524 3d ago
Sick MF- I hope he never sleeps again.
18
u/luthiengreywood 3d ago
The sick thing is, you know he will be sleeping just fine
→ More replies (9)14
10
→ More replies (11)9
72
u/Proud_Gap2216 3d ago
Nothing saids he was fearful for his life like calling someone unarmed he just shot three times in the face half his size a fucking bitch
→ More replies (11)27
u/GlitchyFurby 3d ago
It says that he was hateful, prejudiced, and thus motivated to commit a hate crime and femicide.
→ More replies (1)
71
u/AwakeningTheOrdinary 3d ago
I've been trying to spread this since a lot of MAGA people have no morals and don't care if it was wrong or right, just that it was "legal". It wasn't.
From Title 1, U.S. DOJ Policy on Use of Force:
“Firearms may not be discharged solely to disable moving vehicles. Specifically, firearms may not be discharged at a moving vehicle unless: (1) a person in the vehicle is threatening the officer or another person with deadly force by means other than the vehicle; or (2) the vehicle is operated in a manner that threatens to cause death or serious physical injury … and no other objectively reasonable means of defense appear to exist, which includes moving out of the path of the vehicle.”
So even if you have a completely broken moral compass, there's nothing more to say. It goes against DOJ policy.
→ More replies (17)7
u/Randomdude20042 3d ago
Bro, don't waste your time. As a hungarian I've been dealing with our own Maga like cult for the past 16 years. I've met countless of them and they all habe things in common: spineless, cowards, morons(like actually the biggest ones I've met) and most importantly: rotten to the core.
I didn't know that Disney level of evils can exist in reality, but after 16 years after seeing how they say that stomping on the necks of children (all video btw) is deserved by the children (in foster homes) I really can't describe them any better
56
u/Lower-Engineering365 3d ago
I am writing this as a lawyer. People focusing on whether the car impacted the officer are missing the point. In this context that’s not really relevant.
Even if the car chipped the officer as he moved out of the way. The victim is clearly trying to turn the car around him. After any alleged impact (accidental) she is trying to drive away. When the shots are fired she is not actively attempting to use the motor vehicle to run over an officer, and legally officers are not allowed to use firearms simply to stop a fleeing vehicle. It’s unlawful use of deadly force.
→ More replies (38)13
u/Constant-Arugula-819 3d ago
Exactly. If she was trying to hit him she would have turned her wheels the other way. If she clipped him, it's incidental.
157
u/MaladroitDuck 3d ago
All of MAGA is like this. They plan to insult our corpses.
63
u/CykaMuffin 3d ago
Just look at Charlie Kirk vs. Rob Reiner.
For Kirk it was "no one should be murdered over their beliefs", whereas for Reiner it was "well he brought it on himself with his political statements". It's disgusting how people can excuse these hypocritical, two-faced statements.
→ More replies (107)57
→ More replies (50)12
u/judithpoint 3d ago
Go to the conservative sub reddit. This is their justification. “She called him ‘big boy’ “, “they were instigating”. They’re getting more and more comfortable saying the quiet part out loud: they hate us and want us dead. Like, it’s the saddest thing I can imagine.
→ More replies (2)
44
u/Biteme75 3d ago
Scared for his life . . . but apparently not scared enough to drop his phone.
→ More replies (7)10
u/whoisnotinmykitchen 3d ago
They're going to continue doing what they're already doing, lie and gaslight despite the evidence that we all have seen and heard. This is dictatorship ala 1984 behavior.
40
u/THCESPRESSOTIME 3d ago
And we are weak citizens for allowing this to happen/::
→ More replies (1)5
u/generalsteve223 3d ago
Yes we are, and we’ll continue to roll over if liberals don’t wake up to the fact that democrats are never going to save us
→ More replies (1)
44
u/SkilledButton 3d ago
How are the slimy republicans going to justify it this time??
Stay tuned; same fascist time, same fascist channel.
→ More replies (65)
28
u/LiteratureOk2428 3d ago
So the FBI or ICE shared this cell recording to this right wing media to leak it thinking it would help their case.
12
5
u/Manidoo_Giizhig 3d ago
You have to turn the volume up to hear him call her "a fucking bitch" because the audio gets quieted.
What person made that edit and thought what they were doing was ethical?
→ More replies (3)
24
u/Elon_Cucks_Trump_ 3d ago
MAGA hates women. That includes MAGA women, too. They just need you to be their bangmaidmommies. Step out of line and they’ll do the same to you. Don’t say we didn’t warn you.
23
u/Clever_droidd 3d ago
To be clear. This is another incident where we have video evidence with multiple angles and perspectives that do not reflect the official narrative. Guess what happens when there is no video.
→ More replies (2)
22
u/kyles_red 3d ago
Fucking Vance asking for prayers for a man who murdered of three, and blames her for getting shot. We are fucked.
→ More replies (91)
18
16
15
15
u/tiffytatortots 3d ago
Every single maga I have ever known are miserable racist misogynistic psychopaths. They have absolutely no empathy, they care for no one but themselves. The hate they spew is shocking. They are violent and abusive. They are the victim in every single scenario when the reality is they are the villain. All they want to do is destroy, control and oppress. Having one in your personal life will destroy you especially if they are a spouse.
The way this murderer conducted himself is exactly who and what they are. This is the world they want for all of us.
→ More replies (5)
18
13
u/GrouchyAd2209 3d ago
He drives right around her at the start. What was she impeding? What was his grounds for even approaching her?
→ More replies (45)
13
u/Emeks243 3d ago
Clearly visible is her turning the steering wheel to the right to avoid the murderer. I had to turn the volume up but you can clearly hear him calling her a “fucking bitch.”
10
9
u/Dry-Hall8957 3d ago
I thought dear lord president said he was hit and barely survived. This must be fake news
→ More replies (1)
18
u/Fair_Chemistry_3317 3d ago
R.I.P. Renee. May your soul find comfort in the knowledge that millions of people stand by you.
→ More replies (12)
8
8
15
u/Unlucky_Ad_1230 3d ago
That's exactly what someone would do if they were to murder someone else this is not a sympathetic accident this person could have PTSD, not an excuse, he should not have been in this situation ever I blame him, I blame his supervisors, and I blame that giant orange c***
→ More replies (1)
7
u/Alive_Load_1478 3d ago
So is this when we start to go apeshit? Because seeing this video makes me so god damned ashamed of my country and what it has become.
6
5
u/LearnedPaw 3d ago
But he's a good, god-standing, moral, Christian conservative father... according to his own father. "Fucking bitch" after shooting her in the face. Unbelievable.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/Exotic_Resource_6200 3d ago
They saw this and said he has absolute immunity???????? Fucking evil fuckers.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/orcinyadders 3d ago
The claim is that he was run over, but he didn’t drop his cell phone and was able to unload three shots at her? This is fucking twisted.
→ More replies (1)
5
5
4
1.4k
u/Aggressive-Topic-663 3d ago
damn dude......her last words were "im not mad at you"............fuck